Jules
Apprentice
Posts: 56
|
Post by Jules on Sept 18, 2005 15:58:17 GMT -1
i want to read it too but i`ve to wait till it comes out in germany in october. are they both really so good?
[glow=red,2,300]Jules[/glow]
|
|
|
Post by fanof2books on Sept 18, 2005 16:51:11 GMT -1
i think harry potter is better have u ready the 6th yet it was like the best book ever
|
|
Jules
Apprentice
Posts: 56
|
Post by Jules on Sept 18, 2005 16:58:05 GMT -1
i haven't read HP yet but i will when it comes out in germany in october. i can't wait till it comes out i'm already getting crazy.
jules
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 18, 2005 17:15:05 GMT -1
well fanof2books there is a thread that i also created called the 6th harry potter or something. post in there about harry potter. i didn't like the HBP half as much as i liked eldest.
rosie
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 18, 2005 17:15:39 GMT -1
oh and eragon and eldest r awesome!!!
|
|
Jules
Apprentice
Posts: 56
|
Post by Jules on Sept 18, 2005 17:45:50 GMT -1
ok when u say they r awesome i believe you. i'll get them as soon as i can(i need books i've read all of mine like 30 times)
[glow=red,2,300]Jules[/glow]
|
|
|
Post by [giulietta-off dreaming] on Sept 18, 2005 21:12:58 GMT -1
I FINISHED! *loves it*
|
|
|
Post by [giulietta-off dreaming] on Sept 18, 2005 21:13:45 GMT -1
I can't belive that *censored* is *censored*'s *censored*
*doesn't want to spoil it*
Actually, it was a theory I had. But I dismissed it. And then it actually happened. I think that *censored* is going to join to turn against Galbatorix (take a wild guess who I'm talking about).
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 18, 2005 22:07:13 GMT -1
omigosh, i kno!!!!! ok, now every1 who hasn't read it, Eldest: SPOILERS, BEWARE, SPOILERS is officially a spoiler board!! If u have not read it, don't look down!!!
I'm serious, if u don't want the plot of Eldest spoiled, then don't look down!!
O i know!! i can't believe it was murtagh. and eragon being morazon's son?? unbelieveable!! i think they can find some way to release murtagh. he's really a good guy at heart and they can use that. maybe they could work out a plan where murtagh willingly lets himself be captured by the varden and unable to be forced to help gallbatorix. and the last egg needs to be for the good side. i bet it's like, green or something. o and i hope arya comes to her senses and sees how much eragon loves her!! i kno that i'm not really that accurate in my romantic pairings (coughharryhermionecough) but it seems inevitable, i mean, there's no other girl for eragon, becuase nausda (or however u spell her name) is mortal and with Saphira, eragon is immortal, just like arya.
wasn't it amazing!! rn't u so happy i told u 2 read it first?!?
rosie
|
|
|
Post by [giulietta-off dreaming] on Sept 19, 2005 23:04:41 GMT -1
Yeah, yeah. Oh, and I think the reason Arya keeps rejecting Eragon is 'cause she's already in love (I don't know with who, though, just a wild guess). Oh yeah, and I bet there's more eggs that nobody knows about. And I BET there's going to be a female rider sometime that Eragon can fall in love with.
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 21, 2005 20:14:52 GMT -1
female rider = ahem, Arya? she'd rock as a rider. nah just picking but i hope it's arya. i think she's rejecting him because she thinks he'd young and immature, but i think she'll get over it. i mean, these people live thousands of years old
rosie
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 21, 2005 20:32:40 GMT -1
oh i was just reading eldest and there was this part where eragon was asking arya about ellesmera and her family and arya said something about her guards that were killed by durza, glenwing and some other elf guy that had a funky name. she said that glenwing liked talking to birds, then refused to say anything about funky-name-dude. maybe she was in love with him when he was killed and is now reluctant to love again because she thinks everyone she love will die.
woo hoo, breakthrough for the normally clueless rosie!
|
|
|
Post by Harry potter fan on Sept 22, 2005 19:01:18 GMT -1
Inheritance sucks,brome was a crack smoking old loser who coldnt even kill a ungral. HARRY POTTER IS BETTER Brom is just a knock off of dumbledor off of harry potter once aganine harry potter is better!
|
|
|
Post by [giulietta-off dreaming] on Sept 22, 2005 22:54:22 GMT -1
Harry Potter didn't make it onto my top ten, while Inheritance did. Go post your hate comments somewhere else. Or... erm... never mind.
Oh, and if you're curious, my current top ten:
1. Immortals book 1 (Wild Magic), Pierce 2. Killer Angels, Shaara 3. Legend of Luke, Jacques 4. Mossflower, Jacques 5. Trickster's Queen, Pierce 6. Moonrise, Hunter 7. Eldest, Paolini 8. Stravaganza: City of Flowers, Hoffman 9. Pearls of Lutra, Jacques 10. Stravaganza: City of Masks, Hoffman
It's very random ;D
|
|
|
Post by [giulietta-off dreaming] on Sept 22, 2005 22:58:03 GMT -1
I'll admit that Inheritance is similar to other fantasies-they're ALL alike, have you noticed yet? but Paolini makes it BETTER than most. Oh, and DON'T start talking about LOTR, I absolutely hated it. It was long, tedious, boring, and the chars were really.... I didn't like the way they thought.
Sorry about the double post.
|
|
|
Post by Damien on Sept 22, 2005 23:18:17 GMT -1
im jk eldest rock but i think harry potter is just as good but u see the similaritys in the two characters righ(dumbledor,brom). i havent read eldest yet im rereading eragon first then im ganna read eldest ,whats the best part without giving away anything?
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 24, 2005 20:17:43 GMT -1
i don't like how JKR jumps around and invents a whole bunch of new stuff for every book. paolini ties everything together, but it is completely unpredictable how he does it... i think JKR's on a bit of a killing spree.
o lavita would you mind deleting the eldest hate post? i think it goes unsaid that any complaints about a book u don't like shouldn't be that... mean. instead of raving about how bad something is they should go to the harry potter thread and rave about how good harry is.
o i agree with u guilietta LOTR bugged me. i think the main
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 24, 2005 20:22:11 GMT -1
sry peoples got cut off for a sec. i think the main plot for most of the fellowship of the ring was 'o we're so hungry let's tighten our belts one more notch and curse us for not using more complicated and superfluous words to confuse the audience even more.' grr. it annoyed me.
|
|
|
Post by Rosie on Sept 25, 2005 23:02:41 GMT -1
ok i kno this is a triple post but i'm rereading eldest and i think the reason arya is so opposed to eragon is because she was in love with 1 of her elfin guards, that was killed when durza captured her. his name is faolin and there are several references to him in the book. she described her other guard a bit, but then refused to say anything about faolin, faolin made a flower for arya, and it's her favorite flower now, and there is a fairth of a young elfin man in her room that eragon did not recognize. (that may or may not be faolin) i can't think of anything else, but the way she acts points to this conclusion. clueless rosie is making connections also i think the next rulers of alagaesia will be roran and katrina. alagaesia certainly won't have anymore immortal rulers, (look at the situation they r in now) and paolini has proved in all of his roran parts that roran is a good leader that considers his people before himself. rosie
|
|
|
Post by [giulietta-off dreaming] on Sept 26, 2005 22:20:55 GMT -1
Hmmm... both of those theories are good. *thinks* this is hard...
|
|